Baby Health

10 Best Pacifier For Breastfed Baby in 2022 – Top Picks Review

Best Pacifier For Breastfed Baby

As a parent, you want to ensure that your baby is happy and healthy. One of the most important ways to do this is by making sure they are getting enough sleep every night. A pacifier can help with this in several ways, but before you start giving one to your little one it’s important to make sure that they are breastfeeding well first. If not, it may be best for mommy or daddy to give them the binky instead. Here are some tips on how you might go about doing so! 

Pacifiers also aid in the appropriate alignment of your baby’s teeth and aid in their oral development. They’re available in a variety of shapes, colors, and designs, and they have an anti-slip coating to keep them from falling out of your baby’s mouth.

Why Is A Pacifier Important For A Breastfed Baby? 

A pacifier can be an important tool for a breastfed baby. It can help to soothe a fussy baby, ease the pain of teething, help a baby to fall asleep and it can help to prevent nipple confusion. Additionally, a pacifier can help to promote good oral health in a breastfed baby.

10 Best Pacifier For Breastfed Baby Review

Pacifiers can be used to calm irritable newborns and can also be used during naps and bedtime. They provide a relaxing effect for your child, improve sleeping habits, and provide comfort when they are upset. It can be difficult to choose the ideal pacifier for breastfed babies. However, by conducting the research for you, we have made this work a little easier for you. If you’re not sure which pacifier to include in your wishlist, have a look at our list and reviews of the 10 most popular pacifiers for breastfeeding newborns.

1. Tommee Tippee Day & Night Pacifiers

Tommee Tippee Day & Night Pacifiers Buy: Tommee Tippee Day & Night Pacifiers

Cute pacifiers for babies 3 months and up with glow-in-the-dark handles. I didn’t choose these types of pacifiers when I had my son but now that I am expecting another one in January, they seem like a very good option! I don’t feel like my baby will be aware of the different patterns on them; it’s more to make me happy with cute designs. But glowing in the dark is perfect because you never know if you will wake up at night looking for your baby or not…

I just hope these chewable parts are big enough for this age group. My son was too lazy to hold his pacifier with his hands, he used to drop it all the time. I would love if these came with a small band that you could attach between the nipple and the glow-in-the-dark part.

  • Symmetrical silicone
  • 100% medical grade
  • BPA free
  • Soft and flexible
  • Durable
  • Helps prevent skin irritation
  • Glow in the dark

What We Don’t Like?

  • Need more color options

2. Tommee Tippee Ultra-Light Silicone Baby Pacifier

Tommee Tippee Ultra-Light Silicone Baby Pacifier

Buy: Tommee Tippee  Silicone  Pacifier

Tommee Tippee is a brand known worldwide for its innovative baby products and we are proud that they have chosen our Ultra-Light Silicone Pacifier to offer their parents and babies! This pacifier has been specially designed to meet the highest safety standards but it is also softer than ever so as not to hurt your precious little one’s mouth.

The strong cord between the two halves of the pacifier will keep it from getting lost, dirty, or dropped on the ground where germs can build up quickly. It is easy to sterilize the pacifier nipple and dishwasher safe. With a small integrated nipple, your baby will feel like he/she is suckling from the breast and thus be more at ease. The silicone used provides a soft feeling that is comfortable for your little one’s delicate skin. Ultra-Light Silicone has been developed to meet all safety standards and is free of BPA, latex, and phthalates.

Note: Tommee Tippee Canada does not recommend using this pacifier as a sleep aid or as a soother for unsupervised naps/bedtime with an infant under 3 months due to the risk of SIDS (sudden infant death syndrome). Recommended use: 0-3 months (NIP size 1, 0-6 kg/0-13 lbs.). If you would like to use this product for your newborn, we recommend using the Ultra-Light Cap.

Materials: Polypropylene, silicone nipple, polyamide, elastomer cord, and ABS plastic strap with nylon twill tape backside

  • Ultra-light silicone
  • 100% medical grade
  • Silky soft
  • Durable
  • Dust-free
  • Easy to clean
  • Anti-static properties
  • Hygienic

What We Don’t Like?

  • Quite thick

3. Itzy Ritzy Sweetie Soother Pacifier Setdots

Itzy Ritzy Sweetie Soother Pacifier Setdots

Buy: Itzy Ritzy Sweetie Soother Pacifier

The Award-Winning Itzy Ritzy PaciGrip is made of soft silicone so it doesn’t harm sensitive baby gums. This colorful handcrafted “shoe” is safe for little ones who are teething and helps soothe their gums when they get that familiar ache! The adjustable hook can attach to a car seat, stroller, or diaper bag strap to keep the pacifier close by wherever you go. Baby will love playing with the individual loops on this multicolored plastic ball of fun. Colors may vary slightly from the photo above. Parents will love how easy it is to remove the cover to clean the pacifier in the dishwasher, and you’ll love the price!

Materials: Plastic

Details: Customized with a child’s name up to seven letters long.  The bib is adjustable from 11-13 inches.  Machine washable. Warning: Choking hazard due to small parts. Not for children under 12 months old.

  • 100% food-grade silicone
  • Sold in packs of two
  • Dishwasher safe
  • Great shower gift
  • Easy to clean
  • High-quality

What We Don’t Like?

  • A bit heavy

4. Chicco PhysioForma Silicone Pacifier For Babies

Chicco PhysioForma Silicone Pacifier For Babies

Buy: Chicco PhysioForma Silicone Pacifier

Chicco – For over 50 years Chicco has been a leader in developing innovative products that promote safety and comfort for children. The company’s attention to detail means Chicco offers products with superior design and quality standards.

Babies naturally suck – it soothes them and helps them fall asleep. Babies have been sucking since they were in their mother’s womb. That’s why pacifiers are often recommended by doctors as a helpful tool to support a baby’s emotional development during those first few months after birth. But not all pacifiers are created equally. At CHICCO we’ve devoted more than fifty years to the science of safety, quality, and comfort for infants and toddlers because we know how important it is for parents to be able to focus on their child’s health and happiness.

The latest addition to our range of products, the PhysioForma pacifier, has been carefully designed from start to finish with the baby’s physical comfort in mind. For example, there are no internal seams that can irritate delicate skin – just lots of soft, smooth silicone. The orthodontic nipple is specially designed to develop natural sucking habits and reduce stress on the baby’s jaw.

All this ensures the ultimate long-term oral health of your child. Developed by medical experts with input from parents, the PhysioForma pacifier has been awarded the “red dot” for product design – a highly sought-after award that identifies the best of the best.

Designed by our team of leading international designers and inspired by our range of chic baby strollers, the PhysioForma is a stylish item that makes an excellent gift.

  • 100% silicone
  • BPA and LATEX free
  • Durable
  • Easy to clean
  • Soft

What We Don’t Like?

  • A bit expensive

5. Philips Avent Soothie Pacifier Review

Philips Avent Soothie Pacifier Review

Buy: Philips Avent Soothie Pacifier

Uniquely shaped pacifiers are most commonly used by hospitals for their efficacy in soothing newborn infants. If you’re like me, your little bundle of joy made a fast transition from the womb to an adult-sized body and then gave you a blank look when presented with a standard pacifier. Fortunately, Philips Avent has created a line of newborn products called Soothie which are shaped like little gumdrops.

The product name for this is “newborn friendly” but I found that my daughter was much less fussy when using it compared to other pacifiers, even at 2 months old! The shape may be unique but it feels exactly like a silicone nipple. No wonder she prefers it over her fingers! Moms, you need not worry about nipple confusion since there’s no resemblance to breastfeeding here. Although … come to think of it, maybe that would explain why she loves it so much!

The Gumdrop Soothie has a small set of ventilation holes, which means when the pacifier is placed in the mouth, air can circulate and cool down your baby’s delicate gums. The one-piece construction is great for keeping germs at bay too. To protect against choking, there is a weekly time limit on how long you should use it: once a week or 7 times total before replacement. I recommend you buy more than one pacifier since these are not reusable and babies tend to lose things easily. Note that this product meets the US and European safety standards.

When I first tried to sterilize the paci using boiling water (4 minutes), I noticed that some residue was left on the surface. It’s important to note that this is NOT a medical-grade silicone pacifier, but rather food-grade material. I decided to purchase Soothies by Philips Avent since it was made of 100% medical-grade silicone with no hard plastic components whatsoever. I would recommend you do so as well if safety is your main concern when it comes to picking up baby products for your little one.

  • Unique design
  • Designed for natural oral development
  • Easy to sterilize
  • Durable
  • Value of money
  • Easy to hold

What We Don’t Like?

  • A bit hard

6. NUK Orthodontic Pacifier Value Pack

NUK Orthodontic Pacifier Value Pack

Buy: NUK Orthodontic Pacifier

Description: NUK Orthodontic pacifiers are orthodontic and suitable for newborns. The patented NUK air system lets babies breathe freely. A unique comfort petal, extra soft nipple, and an innovative inside surface create natural feelings when holding the pacifier in the mouth that simulate the mother’s breast when feeding.

I received the Philips Avent Soothie Pacifier for free to test it out with my daughter Jordyn, who was 10 days old at the time of receiving the product. Upon opening our package containing 4 different types of smoothies we were excited to find out which ones our daughter would take to best; however, all of them went to her instantly! We had never seen smoothies before and were very happy that they came with a very handy case to keep all of the smoothies together. It was also fantastic because it means we do not have to go searching for them when in need. Our daughter loves nothing better than to be cuddled and soothed during the night and it is soothing for us as well knowing she can find comfort without disrupting our sleep.

  • Silicone nipple
  • BPA free
  • Giftable
  • Durable
  • Easy to clean
  • High-quality

What We Don’t Like?

  • Long

7. Tommee Tippee Pick-a-Paci Baby Pacifier

Tommee Tippee Pick-A-Paci Baby Pacifier

Buy: Tommee Tippee Baby Pacifier

For all those parents in a rush trying to find baby pacifiers, you can stop looking any further. This 2-pack of Tommee Tippee Pick-a-Paci Baby Pacifiers is the ultimate solution to your problems. The reason why I love this product so much it’s because they are super easy to clean and convenient and the best part is the kid loves them as well.

Hard to lose:

I always had a problem with keeping track of my son’s pacifiers but ever since we came across this product, we never lost his pacifier again! The “pick-a-pacifiers” come two in a pack and can be attached and prevent babies from losing their pacifiers.

  • Breast like a pacifier
  • Kind to baby skin
  • Glow in the dark
  • Orthodontic shape
  • Dust-free zone
  • 100% food-grade silicone

What We Don’t Like?

  • Too big for a 1-month baby

8. Itzy Ritzy Pacifier & Lovey Set; Detachable Plush Llama Toy


Buy: Itzy Ritzy Pacifier

Itzy Ritzy Llama Lovey & Pacifier Set is a detachable plush llama toy that clips onto your baby’s binkie or pacifier to keep it nearby. The lovey also makes a soft bedtime friend for babies because its soft fabric can calm sensitive nervous systems, relieve stress, and reduce anxiety.

The Itzy Ritzy llama lovey are super cute plush toys with the bonus of being able to hold your child’s favorite pacifiers or binkies! The combination of the two is simply genius! These are sure to be hit with any little one. They attach perfectly so you do not have to worry about losing them or having them fall on the ground dirty. These are also made of a soft plush fabric that is not only warm and cozy for your baby but can calm sensitive nervous systems, and reduce anxiety and stress.

They offer the same quality as the more expensive brands at a fraction of the price. I know you want to give your new bundle of joy nothing but the best and Itzy Ritzy has just what you need!

The Itzy Ritzy pacifier & lovey set comes with:

1 detachable plush llama toy with attachment clip for holding binkies or pacifiers 4 brand new BPA Free PVC-Free Soothie Pacifiers by Avent in assorted colors (pink/blue/orange/black) OR 2 brand new BPA Free Soothie Pacifiers by Avent in assorted colors (pink/blue/orange/black) + 1 Soothie Cotton Teething Ring – Green

  • 100% food graded
  • Soft 
  • Giftable
  • Easy to clean
  • Best for teething
  • Light-weight

What We Don’t Like?

  • Too big for one month baby

9. RaZbaby RaZbuddy JollyPop Baby Pacifier

RaZbaby RaZbuddy JollyPop Baby Pacifier

Buy: RaZbaby RaZbuddy Baby Pacifier

The JollyPop pacifier holder’s soft silicone design provides babies with a more comfortable and soothing experience when using their pacifiers. The gentle grip on the back of the pacifier holder makes it effortless to slip in your baby’s pacifier while allowing for easy access when your baby is ready to pop her binky back in.  It also features an adorable “crinkle” noise that will charm any little one!    The JollyPop includes 1 Raz-Berry Silicone Infant Pacifier, which is 100% BPA-free.  

To attach the JollyPop simply stretch over any style of pacifier and gently release.  The JollyPop Pacifier Holder is not a toy and should never be attached to a child’s clothing or other items that could cause a choking hazard.  Do not allow babies to play with JollyPop or remove it from their mouths as it may pose a choking hazard.   The JollyPop Pacifier Holder is also dishwasher safe for easy care – top rack only!

“RaZ-Berry Pacifiers are made of 100% medical grade silicone 1st Choice material, chosen because of its safety record & physicians recommendation.”

  • Light-weight
  • 100% medical grade silicone
  • Detachable from stuffed animal
  • Machine washable
  • Trusted by hospital

What We Don’t Like?

  • Flimsy but super soft

10. Tommee Tippee Woodland Wonders Baby Pacifier Review

Tommee Tippee Woodland Wonders Baby Pacifier Review

Buy: Tommee Tippee Woodland Pacifier

It was a warm September evening in 1987 when my parents bought me a cute little bag of clothes, toys, and other necessities for my baby boy who would come five days later. The only thing in the bag that kept his interest for more than a few seconds was a small light blue pacifier which he continued to chew on even after going to bed that night. It quickly became his favorite “toy” and pretty soon I realized that there were no other pacifiers quite like them anywhere. Thus began our long journey with Tommee Tippee, the company from England which is famous all over the world for its innovative products specially designed for infants.

When our son David grew out of his pacifiers we decided to get the next best thing – one of their so-called “nipples” or pacifier holders. We have been hooked on these things ever since because they are not only great for babies but also toddlers, perhaps even older children who just love to carry around a “baby toy”.

The Woodland Wonders line is one of Tommee Tippee’s newest. As you can see here, it consists of several playful cartoonish animal designs which your baby will certainly enjoy for many months to come. The set we received includes an elephant, a giraffe, and a zebra (the pink one in the picture).

My son was excited when he saw his new friends (he still prefers animals over human beings) and proceeded to suck on them immediately. I must say that the nipple part of these pacifiers is one of the best around (if not THE best) because it is made from a special kind of rubber called “Silicone Active”. This material is patented by Tommee Tippee and it’s supposed to be more hygienic, anti-bacterial, and stronger than any other pacifier around. It’s also tasteless so I don’t think it will upset your baby’s stomach (although I must mention that the nipple doesn’t contain BPA as other pacifiers do).

  • Flexes like mum
  • Kind to baby’s skin
  • For newborns and older babies
  • Perfect for a breastfed baby
  • Soft and comfortable

What We Don’t Like?

  • Heavy

Buyer’s Guide

1. The pacifier should be shaped like a nipple 

2. It should have the same texture as the mom’s skin to make it more comforting for baby 

3. The pacifier shouldn’t contain any artificial sweeteners, flavors, or colors 

4. Choose a silicone one that is easy to clean and doesn’t pose any health risks if swallowed by your baby

5. Look for ones that are BPA-free and made from natural rubber latex (rather than synthetic)

Final Thoughts 

If you’re looking for the best baby pacifier that is the best in terms of comfort, quality, and durability, this article will point one out to you. The 10 products we’ve reviewed are all worthy contenders – but which one do you think deserves your vote? We want to know what makes each product unique from the other ones on our list so please write us a comment below with any thoughts or insights. Thank you!

Renae Reinardy

Hi, my name is Renae. I started Blogging with my friends LaTarsha Holdenton and keren Smooth under the company name “K2babycare” to share my knowledge of parenting with other Moms, to become a better Mom tomorrow than today.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published.